H P Lovecraft was an unabashed racist. He hated Jews, blacks, and
non-white immigrates, and did not hesitate to say so. What shall we make of this today?
Nnedi Okorafor, a fantasy writer who received an award which came with
a bust of Lovecraft, is a member of a group he hated. Hatred of
blacks still exists today, and is an important moral-political issue.
She objected to the choice of trophy, and got it changed.
I too am a member of a group he hated, and that hatred still exists
today. Antisemitism is also an important moral-political issue. But
I don't think it matters much today what Lovecraft's opinions were a
century ago, about these points or any other. He has no political
influence now.
So our choice is whether to dwell on his politics, or let it be
forgotten and think about him only for his fiction.
I think the latter is wiser, overall. The change Ms Okorafor achieved
was, marginally, a step forward, but there is no point pushing it
further. There are so many bigots alive today, and so many practices
that are part of systemic racism, that de-Lovecraftizing literary
activities on account of his bigotry is a distraction from effective
activism.
I would not be reluctant to read his work knowing that he would have
hated me if he had met me, just as I wouldn't hesitate to listen to
Wagner for the like reason. As it happens, I don't especially like
their work, but that is a different matter.