PROJET AUTOBLOG


Richard Stallman's Political Notes

Site original : Richard Stallman's Political Notes

⇐ retour index

Tintin series of graphic novels

mardi 15 août 2023 à 12:03

The famous Tintin series of graphic novels from Belgium included adventures in the Belgian Congo, and they depicted realities of colonization. There have been demands to censor the books over that.

When it comes to judging Belgian colonialism, we need not bother thinking of Tintin. The realities of the Congo were oppression from beginning to end. Initially, the Congo was King Leopold's personal possession, and he treated the inhabitants so cruelly that even the main European colonial powers (exploiters themselves) were ashamed of it. That took some doing.

We can't change the past, but that part of the past calls for vigorous condemnation.

The question here, though, is whether to attack the fictional Tintin books today as a stand-in for the real exploitation of real people in the past.

The passages criticized in the article clearly depict aspects of the colonial system. Whether they were specifically vicious, or merely illustrated aspects of a system which was vicious overall, depends on the specific context, which the article does not go into.

Be that as it may, to try to "sanitize" Tintin by falsifying the parts that refer in passing to the colonial system would be pointless damage, that would not do any good against present and future injustice, let alone past injustice.

What could do good is to add an appendix to point out the glimpses of the colonial system in the story, and give the start of an overall picture of the oppression that those glimpses showed parts of. Today's readers could learn something important from that.