PROJET AUTOBLOG


Richard Stallman's Political Notes

Site original : Richard Stallman's Political Notes

⇐ retour index

Tearing down of statues

mardi 16 juin 2020 à 02:00

In Albania, tearing down statues of the Communist regime made it harder to remember, and notice the aspects of injustice that persisted, or got worse.

Statues of the champions of injustice call attention to them and lionize them. Tearing down the statues ends the lionization but makes it easy to forget what they did. How can we end the lionization and encourage attention to political issues about them.

Would building prison cells around the statues be a useful approach for some of them? For many of them, there are grounds to sentence them to tens of thousands of years in prison, even in some cases millions of years. The prison cell could be permanent.

Another idea is to replace the statues with a holiday celebrating the end of the bad things they did — for instance, in the US, an annual holiday to celebrate the defeat of the Confederacy.

Disputes are developing over whether to remove statues of controversial people who are mainly known for doing something generally agreed to be good, but also professed bigotry — for instance, Baden-Powell who founded scouting, and Winston Churchill who, more than anyone else, defeated Hitler's empire.

I think Churchill's statues should remain. He was racist and a colonialist (almost everyone in the UK was that), he defended the power of the rich (most Britons disagreed, and voted in Labour before the end of the war), and his decisions caused a deadly famine in Bengal. Those are large wrongs. Yet he did an enormous good: Churchill, more than anyone else, defeated Hitler's empire. On the balance, I think he still deserves admiration, with attention also to his wrongs.